Among these, flat plate and evacuated tube collectors are of a particular interest. Considering the heating requirements and environmental conditions three types of solar thermal collectors are employed, such as flat plate collector, evacuated tube solar collector and concentrated solar collector. Solar energy is used for variety of heating systems such as domestic hot water systems and industrial applications. Current developments in flatplate vacuum solar thermal collectors. Performance characteristics for vacuum flat plate collector alternatives have been derived.
Hstc alongside highend flat plate and evacuated tube solar collectors. Evacuated flat plate efp solar thermal collectors are anticipated to combine the high fill. Data was sampled at a rate of 2 hz using a 16bit data acquisition system. Modeling of flatplate solar collector operation in transient states. Mod12 lec12 theory of flat plate collectors liquid.
A single etc30 tube collector is ideal for residential households of 45 people, able to provide 6080% of domestic hot water demand depending on location for commercial projects that demand a lot more hot water such as such as hotels, dormitories and car washes, multiple etc30 collectors can be connected to form a larger solar thermal array. Investigation of evacuated tube collector performance at high temperature mode using trnsys simulation model. The connection between flat plate collector and the storage tank is a simple design. Evacuated flat plate collectors are a possible alternative to. Flat plate collectors have glass on top and have blackened metallic absorbers inside and riser tubes to carry water. Flatplate collector sun600 technical datasheet nr 95. The flat plate collector has been around forever at least since the 1890s.
They can be very expensive compared to flat plate collectors or batch solar collectors, though some of the integrated tank collectors are the cheapest to purchase and operate as they dont need most of the balanceofsystem components. Strangely enough, many people weigh in, and take different sides. Feb 08, 20 flat plate collectorsa flat plate collector is basicly a black surface that is place d ata convenient path of the sun. Analysis of a flat plate solar collector fabio struckmann dept. Cant find the source of that, but for the record i dont think they should. Most flat plate collectors have two horizontal pipes at the top and bottom, called headers, and many smaller vertical pipes connecting them, called risers. Its ventilation concept offers an optimal protection in maritime water and desert environment sand. A cross section of a single evacuated tube with absorber plate is shown in figure 4 figure 4.
Thermal analysis of evacuated tube collectors to create a thermal circuit so that heat transfer from the surface of the collector tube to the copper tubes can be explained. Many evacuated tube collectors appear to have much lower efficiencies than flatplate collectors because the tubes have space between them, which makes the efficiency based on gross area appear low, but are not indicative of overall system performance. Performance of evacuated flat plate solar thermal collectors. And a typical flat plate collectoris a metal box with a glass or plastic cover called glazing ontop and a darkcolored absorber plate on the bottom. Flat plate versus evacuated tubes solar water heating. This is an incredibly common question in the solar thermal industry. Evacuated tube collectors compared with the thermo dynamics liquidflatplate collector there are two competing technologies for solar domestic hot water systems the evacuated tube collector etc and the liquid flat plate lfp collector. The effects of these parameters on the performance of the solar collector were also investigated. Evacuated tube collector while plat plate collectors are all essentially made the same way and perform the way from one.
A simple flat plate solar energy collector consists basically of an absorbing surface which absorbs the insolation and transmit it in form of heat to a working fluid commonly air or water. Solar energy collectors are basically distinguished by their motion such as fixed, single axes and two axis. Evacuated tubes tend to have lighter components and are easier to manage on the roof. Design and performance of evacuated solar collector microchannel. Evacuated tube collectors are more efficient than flat plate collectors. Solar thermal flat plate or evacuated tube collectors. Abstractvacuum flat plate solar thermal collectors offer. Flatplate and evacuatedtube solar collectors are mainly used to collect heat for. One of them contains 120 flat plate collectors and works for the preparation of hot water in a swimming pool.
Flat plate collector, type sv and sh for installation on flat and pitched roofs. Annual fraction and heating loads for different solar collector areas and number of people is estimated. The analysis follows that for normal flat plate collectors with simplifications introduced by ignoring the conduction and convection heat transfer from the absorber plate to the glass tube since high vacuum normally exists inside the glass tube. Evacuated tube collectors are made of a glass tube where the outer covering absorbs the solar radiation and the heat generated is transferred to the flowing water. It is difficult to maintain the vacuum over a long period of time, since ambient air will always find a way between the glass and the housing to get into the collector, and an evacuated flat plate collector therefore has to be evacuated again from time to time. The sizes of flat plate and evacuated tube collectors with heat. In contrast to solar hot water panels, they use a circulating fluid to displace heat to a separated reservoir. Evacuated tube collectors compared with the thermo dynamics. Flat plate collector fpc flat 1 3080 evacuated tube collector etc flat 1 50200 compound parabolic collector cpc tubular 15 60240 singleaxis tracking 515 60300. In this paper the technical details and results of the comparison of the thermal performance of evacuated tube and flat plate type solar collectors in nordic climate conditions are presented. Image no1 flat plate collector 1,000 btuft2day 12 times less heat in cool and cloudy conditions this alone tell you that these evacuated tube collectors produce more heat in canadian climates than this flat plate collectors will well known, flat plate collector srcc data. Flat plate versus evacuated tubes solar water heating solar. In poland, various solar collector systems are used. Flat plate collector an overview sciencedirect topics.
Progress and latest developments of evacuated tube solar collectors. A flat plate panel has insulation at the back and sides, with glass on top, and isnt so efficient per square metre. Packaged solar systems solar pv systems evacuated tube solar collectors flat plate solar collectors thermosiphon water heater pump stations solar controllers hot water tanks. They can be of the concentrating or the flat plate type. Evacuated tube collector an overview sciencedirect topics. Moss1 and stan shire1 1 school of engineering, university of warwick, uk abstract solar thermal collectors for buildings have traditionally used either a flat panel or evacuated tube design. Mesquita department of mechanical and materials engineering, queens university, kingston, on, k7l 3n6, canada abstract solar collectors may reach high temperatures during power failures or periods when there is minimal heat removal. High efficiency evacuated flatplate solar collector for process steam production article pdf available in solar energy 652. Flat plate and evacuated tube solar collectors are mainly used to collect heat for space heating, domestic hot water, or cooling with an absorption chiller. Evacuated flat plate efp solar thermal collectors are anticipated to combine the high fill factor, ease of cleaning and visual aesthetics of flat plate collectors with the low heat loss coefficient of evacuated tubes.
Comparison of thermal and output efficiencies how to compare. The simplest design is that which contains one circular fluid conduit. Solar collector, thermal, vacuum, flat panel, heat transfer. The flow pipe is connected with the inlet rings, the cold water to the collector and a pipe connected with outlet side gets the heated water out from the. With evacuated tubes, the vacuum provides almost perfect insulation. Mod12 lec12 theory of flat plate collectors liquid based a nptelhrd.
We have models from 26 ft2 up to 40 ft2, many of which are srcc og100 certified to maximize rebates and performance guarantees. The apricus fpca32 flat plate solar thermal collector is suitable for residential or commercial solar water heating projects. Performance testing of evacuated tubular collectors. In really cold under 50f weather, flat panel collectors collect little or no heat. Installation manual certificate of warranty and label with bar code. One collector that is particularly at home here is manufactured by tvp solar sa from switzerland. High performance flat plate solar thermal collector evaluation. Performance and operational effectiveness of evacuated flat plate. Etc30 solar collector, evacuated tube solar collectors. Welcome to the navitron evacuated tube solar collector. Pdf high efficiency evacuated flatplate solar collector. A wide variety of evacuated tube collector options are available to you, such as vacuum solar collector, pressurized, and u pipe. Image no2 evacuated tube collector 12,000 btuft2day.
The comparison of solar energy gaining effectiveness. One area of research in solar thermal collectors, therefore, seeks to combine the benefits of. Com superior performance sunmaxx solar collectors are among the best performing and most efficient in the solar thermal industry cuttingedge technology built with the latest processes, materials and bestpractices included seamless welding and much more. Different parameters like optical design, optimum operating conditions. Request pdf on jul 7, 2015, m a sabiha and others published progress and latest developments of evacuated tube solar collectors find. The price of the flat plate solar water heating collector is going to depend on two main factors, namely the size and the design. The research investigated the variations of top loss heat transfer coefficient with absorber plate emittance. Characteristic values of flat plate and evacuated tube collectors qcoll is the energy collected per unit collector area per unit time fr is the collector s heat removal factor. Detailed modeling of flat plate solar collector with vacuum. A flat plate collector is basically an insulated box with glass on one side and copper tubing running through absorber plates. The relative cost of solar thermal collector installations fariborz mahjouri, phd thermo technologies 5560 sterrett place, suite 115.
Whether you have just purchased your collector or are researching before you buy you have taken an important step to reducing pollution and carbon dioxide emission, whilst enjoying piping hot water heated by nature. For example in a cool climate, you could need 2 or 3 flat panel collectors to produce the same heat as 1 evacuated tube collector. Collector sizing guide depending on your region and size of system solar can provide between 5090% of your domestic hot water needs. The simplest flat plate collectors are the solar ponds and the solar stills which operate by direct utilization of the incident solar radiation acting simultaneously as solar energy converters. Evacuated tube solar collectors consist of evacuated glass tubes and solar working fluid usually with a cocktail of antifreeze and are used to heat domestic water and internal spaces.
Evacuated tube collectors can outperform flat plate collectors and flat plate collectors. A large plate of blackened material is oriented in such a manner that the solar energy that falls on the pl. Comparison sheet evacuated heat pipe collectors versus flat. These collectors are fieldtested and ready for use in nearly all climates and locations. Combining the two established technologies, an evacuated flat panel design would be. The first solar thermal collector designed for building roofs was patented by william h. Flatplate and evacuated tube collectors springerlink.
Flat plate collectors typically cost less from the outset than evacuated. Flat plate solar collectors, solar collector apricus solar. Etv08 evacuated tube solar collectors come individually packed in a wooden crate. Heat loss is minimised by the vacuum in the tubes, which means that evacuated tube solar collectors generate more heat than flat plate collectors. Flat plate collectors contain water and unless well protected can burst upon freezing.
Pdf investigation of evacuated tube collector performance. Producer should fully disclose the parameters of the collectors parameters of collectors are determined according to uniform eu standards, namely en12975 and available at. Evacuated flat plate efp solar thermal collectors are anticipated to. The various types of collectors including flat plate, compound parabolic, evacuated tube, parabolic trough, fresnel lens, parabolic dish and heliostat field collectors were followed by an optical, thermal and thermodynamic analysis of the collectors and a description of the methods used to evaluate their performance. The importance of flatplate collectors is that their thermal performance can be predicted and treated in considerable detail. Design and performance of evacuated solar collector. Hot water flat panel vs evacuated tube solar pv discussion.
Pdf a flatplate solar collector for process steam production was. Thermal analysis of evacuated solar tube collectors. Flat plate collectors v evacuated tubes a brief overview. Theres a link on this page and over at the solar panel article saying that someone suggested that the two articles should be combined. Evacuated tube solar collectors are often initially more expensive than flat plate solar collectors.
A theoretical analysis of flat plate solar collectors with a vacuum glazing is presented. Evacuated tubes tend to be more fragile than flat plates. Characteristic values of flatplate and evacuated tube collectors qcoll is the energy collected per unit collector area per unit time fr is the collectors heat removal factor. Different configurations of the collector have been investigated by a detailed theoretical model based on a combined external and internal energy balance of the absorber. High performance flat plate solar thermal collector. Classification of solar collectors depending of number of covers in fig. This type of solar collector has a good cost effectiveness ratio in moderate climates and adapts correctly to a large number of applications of solar thermal energy heating of sanitary water, heating of swimming pools, support for heating, preheating industrial. This report summarises the work carried out within the qaist project in the field of evacuated tubular collectors.
Flat plate thermal solar collectors are the most commonly used type of solar collector. Two evacuated flat panel collectors were built and tested under a solar simulator. The flat plate evacuated tube collector consists of multiples of evacuated glass tubes in which one or two axial fluid conduits are located axially and attached to a selective absorber plate. A properly sized system will provide almost all of a homes hot water in the summer months. Jul 22, 2010 should you choose evacuated tube solar collectors or flat plate solar collectors for your diy solar hot water or solar he. Efficiency improvement of flat plate solar collector using. Collectors are usually oversized in order to satisfy a heat demand and this increases their manufacturing cost. The work was focusing on performance testing and quality assurance issues. A cross section of a single evacuated tube with absorber plate is shown in figure 4. This idea has been perpetuated mainly by manufacturers of evacuated tube collectors, but unfortunately their claims are often not. Evacuated tubes a brief overview since their conception, the evacuated tube collector has been commonly heralded around the solar industry as the more efficient collector.
So in the winter months in cooler climates with et you may be able to reduce the amount of gas or electric boosting required compared with flat plate. Simulator testing of evacuated flat plate solar collectors. Flat panel solar collector experiment part 3 duration. The evacuated heat pipe collectors the evacuated heat pipe solar collector is the result of extensive research, development and testing. The performance of evacuated tube solar collectors is better when compared to flat plate collector in high temperature applications. There are different solar collector types such as flat plate, evacuated and concentrated. Zbyslaw pluta institute of heat engineering, warsaw university of technology 2125 nowowiejska street, 00665 warsaw, poland abstract evacuated tubular solar collectors are increasingly used all over the world due to their low coe cients of heat losses to the environment. The flat plate solar collector is a type of solar thermal panel whose objective is to transform solar radiation into thermal energy. Due to the simplicity of design, the flat plate collectors are extensively used for water heating.
Flat plate and evacuated tube type collectors are compared and analysed. Do not have the same level of corrosion problems as flat plate collectors. Oct 06, 2009 a comparison of two solar hot water technologies. An experimental study on evacuated tube solar collector. In general, fixed collectors are used due to economical factors. Flat plates can actually rob the water of built up heat if the collector becomes colder than the water temperature. If its hot and sunny, it becomes a nonissue, either type will produce all the hot water you can use. It is useful to develop an overall loss coefficient for a flat plate evacuated tube collector.
A solar thermal collector collects heat by absorbing sunlight. But this investment can be recouped quickly, due to the increased performance of these collectors in a wider variety of climates and conditions. Evacuated tube solar collectors are very efficient and can achieve very high temperatures. System design guide 5167 156 03 042016 vitosol r vitosol 100f vitosol 200f vitosol 200t, spe. Flat plate solar collectors sunmaxx has a complete line of titanpower tm and titanpowerplus flat plate solar collectors. The highvacuum flat plate collector reachers peak yields by avoiding convection losses inside the. In the last one, a heat pipe with a twophase system is used for absorbing and. Evacuated tube solar collectors have been designed in different models such as utube, direct flow, glassglass, and heat pipe. So, the evacuated tube is considered to be an important component in thermal application, particularly in solar water heating systems 1. Flat plate collectors are an extension of the basic idea to place a collector in an ovenlike box with glass in the direction of the sun. Often graphs comparing flat plate collectors with evacuated tube collectors are based on gross area, which shows the evacuated tube collector with a yintercept of only 4045%, and the flat plate. Like a red sox vs yankees type of rivalry, its a heated debate. Require a smaller roof area than comparable flat plate collectors. One of the important issues is obtaining a good thermal bond between the absorber plate and changes tubes or ducts containing the heattransfer fluids.
With innovative collector designs, new applications have opened up for solar thermal energy, such as solar cooling, process heat generation and combined heat and power chp. Generally, evacuated tubes perform better in colder andor cloudier conditions than their flat panel counterparts. Feb 16, 2016 in 5 the exergy analysis for a single ended glass evacuated tube solar collector system was carried out. The flat plate collector features a low profile design 80mm 3. Pdf high efficiency evacuated flatplate solar collector for process. These disadvantages can be avoided with evacuated tube collectors. Should i choose evacuated tube or flat plate solar collector. The key considerations in flat plate collector design are maximizing absorption, minimizing reflection and radiation losses, and effective heat transfer from the collector plate to the fluids. Concerning domestic hot water preparation and room heating pdf.
587 197 940 898 571 545 985 554 495 160 488 164 1209 36 1275 1293 543 821 1182 705 530 1315 58 1244 454 408 827 1457 3 997 1224 65 197